People of Good Will Can Respectfully Disagree! The Church Crisis Continues

This is a sincere and thoughtful podcast, and I appreciate Mother Miriam's views However,  I strongly disagree with her conclusion that the SSPX consecrations should not have taken place. The pope is not only in conflict with Church doctrine, but with most of the pre-Vatican II popes. There certainly is a crisis in the Church which becomes ever more obvious on a daily basis. People can differ on the response to the crisis. It would be a blessing if everyone would assume the good will of others, especially their desire to do God's will in all things. I don't doubt Mother Miriam's sincere conscience disagreement with the SSPX decision. I would greatly appreciate her recognition of the sincere conscience disagreement of the laity, the bishops, and the priests of the Society who believe the severe crisis in the Church necessitated the consecrations.

On the FSSP Chaplaincy in Front Royal and the SSPX

St. Francis de Sales advises the faithful to always put the best construction on other people's actions and the most critical on your own. So I will do that with Bishop Burbidge's decision to invite the FSSP to start a chaplaincy here in Virginia. Since it is being formed "to serve primarily in Front Royal," it doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize that a primary purpose is to close (by attrition) the SSPX chapel currently in Linden "which remains in a state of irregular communion."

I can't read the bishop's mind but I will presume that he really does care about his diocesan flock and not just the money the diocese is losing which, in view of the on-going SSPX building fund donations, is approaching two million dollars.