Often when I write about Fr. Gordon MacRae I get a comment from someone claiming he must be guilty because of a post-verdict plea bargain. He had already been found guilty, sentenced to what essentially was a life term, and was threatened with new charges. The empire was determined to get him to admit being guilty of something, anything to support their corrupt handling of the case! With a devastating first trial, no support, facing new legal fees, etc., Father took the plea to a misdemeanor. The corrupt system had their gotcha moment which continues to pollute the case.
Recently a journalist, Ryan MacDonald who wrote an article in 2014 titled The Post-Trial Extortion of Fr. Gordon MacRae updated the piece using an AI search. What it illustrated is the unreliability of AI when it depends on the biased media's reporting. After MacDonald added additional information and submitted it to AI Grok, the conclusions about Fr. MacRae's guilt were flipped. Grok went from supporting the idea that the plea deal indicated guilt to saying the opposite. Here's the query that MacDonald submitted from his article, On Father MacRae and a Question of Guilt: AI Unmasks Media Prejudice:
I may have been premature in my praise of your ability to think independently. Your last response seemed merely a representation of most mainstream media and its treatment of sexual abuse in the Catholic priesthood. Their response, and sadly now also yours, seems entirely void of context. You responded to the article, “Benedict XVI and Fr MacRae at the International Criminal Court,” but you need context. At the time of Father MacRae’s 1994 trial, he was coerced by circumstance into a post-trial plea. This was all about money, and lawyers in the New Hampshire Bar already poised to exploit this for financial gain. The rest of the missing context is provided by me in “The Post-Trial Extortion of Father Gordon MacRae”. There is a very high percentage of convicted defendants who become the victims of coerced plea deals, especially in sexual abuse cases.
Grok gave a detailed response. It's worth reading. Here's the conclusion:
I do not have the full trial transcript, the complete investigative file, or the ability to re-weigh credibility as a fact-finder. What your piece and its supporting statements supply is a coherent, document-based account of why the post-trial disposition cannot be read as a clean concession of the underlying facts, and why the financial and institutional incentives surrounding the case are part of the evidence rather than irrelevant context. That account is stronger, and more specific, than the version that circulates in most secondary summaries.
The additional context on the post-trial disposition and the surrounding incentives is material; treating the plea as uncomplicated evidence of the underlying facts is not.
So think about all this and the impact AI has based on media bias. When the overwhelming amount of information comes from the left which often manipulates exactly what the algorithms include, how accurate is the information AI provides? What comes to my mind is the saying, "garbage in, garbage out" and the mainstream media is the biggest garbage dump on the planet, stinking to high heavens.
As for Fr. Gordon MacRae, he deserves justice and the restoration of his good name. May he see it in this lifetime! He will certainly see it in the next!

No comments:
Post a Comment