I've only read the first three books in the Harry Potter series. The beginning of the fourth was so disturbing I set it aside and have not picked it up again. I began to read the books because of the controversy over whether they introduce children to the occult. And, of course, they do. Are they dangerous? I believe they can be. Think of the children you see dressed in gothic attire and sporting tattoos, body piercings, and freakish hair colors and styles. I think "games" like Dungeons and Dragons and books like Harry Potter have real potential to damage these children further. What do you think?
Here's an article you might find interesting after watching the video below. Rowlings certainly seems to have an intimate knowledge of the occult. Did she gain it researching her books or has she actually practiced the black arts? Is the book dangerous to the formation of conscience? Can it undermine children's ability to make good moral decisions? There is so much good reading out there, should parents steer their children away from Harry Potter? Join the debate. What do you think?
Search This Blog
Showing posts with label Harry Potter. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Harry Potter. Show all posts
Wednesday, July 20, 2011
Thursday, February 19, 2009
More on Harry Potter
A reader sent me a fascinating article on Harry Potter after reading my post the other day. It's certainly worth a look and I appreciate the views of Catholic writer Regina Doman. I think her point that authors can write sound books while living unsound lives is spot on. I think of Oscar Wilde whose children's stories are delightful and whose Picture of Dorian Gray is a chilling description of how sin putrifies the soul. Wilde was a tortured man. It never surprised me, though, to find that he converted to the Catholic faith on his deathbed. There's an interesting article about this called The Long Conversion of Oscar Wilde by Andrew McCracken. It describes Wilde's long journey to the Catholic faith and his eleventh hour surrender.
And then there's one of my favorite authors Mark Twain who professed atheism and rejected a god that is completely alien to the One I know. If we receive our "image of God" from the Christians around us, perhaps Twain's atheism says more about the people he lived among than about God. I only know that his novel on St. Joan of Arc is a story of such beauty (It was his favorite.) that I can't imagine him not making it to heaven despite the dark works like Letters from the Earth. Besides, he had an incredible sense of humor, real humor that tickles the heart and stimulates joyful laughter. There is no such thing as humor in hell, only the filthy snicker and the snide smirk.
Enjoy Regina's article which is one more yea for Harry Potter. Her insights encourage me to pick up the series where I left off.
And then there's one of my favorite authors Mark Twain who professed atheism and rejected a god that is completely alien to the One I know. If we receive our "image of God" from the Christians around us, perhaps Twain's atheism says more about the people he lived among than about God. I only know that his novel on St. Joan of Arc is a story of such beauty (It was his favorite.) that I can't imagine him not making it to heaven despite the dark works like Letters from the Earth. Besides, he had an incredible sense of humor, real humor that tickles the heart and stimulates joyful laughter. There is no such thing as humor in hell, only the filthy snicker and the snide smirk.
Enjoy Regina's article which is one more yea for Harry Potter. Her insights encourage me to pick up the series where I left off.
Monday, February 16, 2009
Harry Potter -- Yes or No?
Over the years I've read plenty of commentary on Harry Potter. Some folks think the series was spawned in hell; others love it and think it's filled with great Christian imagery. I read the first few and thought they were okay for a child to read with close adult supervision, but I found some things in the books troubling. I think the series can be a real danger for kids in troubled homes or who have little wise adult guidance. I think they can also be a danger for badly catechized adults, the same type to be taken in by The DaVinci Code. (I was appalled how many ignorant Catholics believed it.) When I got to the fourth Potter book that started with a brutal murder I knew it definitely was not for twelve-year-olds. And yet how many parents pay attention to what their children are reading?What do you think? Here are a few articles looking at both sides.
Voting YEA --
HARRY POTTER, PAPIST? , a review of The Mystery of Harry Potter: A Catholic Family Guide by Nancy Carpentier Brown
Not the Power of Success but the Humbleness of Giving Himself (This link also pulls up the first article below.)
Voting NAY --
A Wrong Image of the Hero
Harry Potter: An Entry Point into the World of the Occult / New Age Movement
See a list of nays at Steve Wood's website. Wood has experience with the occult so his opinion carries some weight I think.
Wood also goes into Pullman's series, His Dark Materials. Pullman portrays the Catholic Church as the enemy and the demonic as the good. The series is the fulfillment of the prophecy that there will come a time when good is called evil and evil good. We're there big time. Is Harry Potter the "entry drug" into the occult?
Harry Potter: Agent of Conversion by Toni Collins This last article I found particularly interesting because the author came out of the occult and shares her views both yea and nay about the series. This is a defiinite must read for parents.
Labels:
Harry Potter,
His Dark Materials,
new age,
Pullman
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)